I was googling to get headline ideas and found these. Sharing it here for good karma. This is a pretty nice list.
1. Give Me [short time period] and I’ll Give You [blank]. 2. If You Don’t [blank] Now, You’ll Hate Yourself Later. 3. The Lazy [blank’s] Way to [blank]. 4. Do You Recognize the [number] Early Warning Signs of [blank]? 5. See How Easily You Can [desirable result]. 6. You Don’t Have to Be [something challenging] to be [desired result]. 7. Do You Make These Mistakes? 8. Who Else Wants [blank]? 9. The Secret of [blank] 10. Here is a Method That is Helping [blank] to [blank] 11. Little Known Ways to [blank] 12. Get Rid of [problem] Once and For All 13. Here’s a Quick Way to [solve a problem] 14. Now You Can Have [something desirable] [great circumstance] 15. [Do something] like [world-class example] 16. Have a [or] Build a [blank] You Can Be Proud Of 17. What Everybody Ought to Know About [blank]
I found these on CopyBlogger.com - http://www.copyblogger.com/10-sure-fire-headline-formulas-that-work/
HI Church...tell us more about the goals of your site and we can better advise. What's the #1 action you want someone to take on the site?
Also - I notice your site breaks and is completely unreadable for someone using Firefox. You should get this fixed soon. A good chunk of your users could be seeing a broken page.